FIDE Rebukes Kramnik's Defamation Suit Against Navara, Cites Damage to Chess Community; Aronian Urges Reconciliation

The International Chess Federation (FIDE) has released a strong statement addressing the ongoing dispute between former World Champion GM Vladimir Kramnik and Czech GM David Navara. FIDE expressed serious concerns about the negative impact of the situation on the chess community and called for a return to mutual respect.

Chess Grandmaster Vladimir Kramnik (Photo by Antony Jones/Getty Images for World Chess)

FIDE reaffirmed its dedication to upholding fair play in both traditional and online chess, acknowledging the increasing significance of online platforms. The organization confirmed the establishment of a task force to analyze the statistical methods proposed by Kramnik for detecting potential cheating. While inviting Kramnik to submit his data for official review, FIDE cautioned that his public commentary has been detrimental.

FIDE's statement emphasized the potential damage caused by Kramnik's public accusations: "We are gravely concerned that the way Mr. Kramnik presents his points brings a lot of harm to the chess community. Coming from the former World Champion, it could be ruinous for the careers and well-being of certain players."

FIDE voiced its support for GM David Navara, describing him as "a paragon of fair play" known for his "great sensitivity and integrity." The organization highlighted Navara's vulnerability to reputational damage and psychological distress resulting from the public accusations.

The controversy escalated when Kramnik filed a civil defamation lawsuit in Geneva against Navara, Chess.com, and Chessdom, stemming from public disagreements over online cheating allegations.

In response to the situation, Armenian GM Levon Aronian penned an emotional open letter to Kramnik, urging reconciliation and reflection.

Addressing Kramnik as one of his "chess parents," Aronian expressed his past admiration for Kramnik's resilience and brilliance, but implored him to reconsider the legal action, stating, "You are fighting your own demons."

FIDE concluded its statement by urging Kramnik to withdraw the lawsuit: "We sincerely hope that GM Kramnik will take this morally justified step, which we believe will be welcomed by the broader chess world."